by the meltingpot: The genesis of the dam

Now Reading!

Indeed, what is at work in the recent return of realism is the revenge of geography in the most old-fashioned sense. In the 18th and 19th centuries, before the arrival of political science as an academic specialty, geography was an honored, if not always formalized, discipline in which politics, culture, and economics were often conceived of in reference to the relief map. Thus, in the Victorian and Edwardian eras, mountains and the men who grow out of them were the first order of reality; ideas, however uplifting, were only the second.
And yet, to embrace geography is not to accept it as an implacable force against which humankind is powerless. Rather, it serves to qualify human freedom and choice with a modest acceptance of fate. This is all the more important today, because rather than eliminating the relevance of geography, globalization is reinforcing it. Mass communications and economic integration are weakening many states, exposing a Hobbesian world of small, fractious regions. Within them, local, ethnic, and religious sources of identity are reasserting themselves, and because they are anchored to specific terrains, they are best explained by reference to geography. Like the faults that determine earthquakes, the political future will be defined by conflict and instability with a similar geographic logic. The upheaval spawned by the ongoing economic crisis is increasing the relevance of geography even further, by weakening social orders and other creations of humankind, leaving the natural frontiers of the globe as the only restraint.
So we, too, need to return to the map, and particularly to what I call the “shatter zones” of Eurasia. We need to reclaim those thinkers who knew the landscape best. And we need to update their theories for the revenge of geography in our time.
Here is the link for the whole write up.

Now at 2nd place

My view is that relations between countries in the coming decades are most likely to reflect their cultural commitments, their cultural ties and antagonism with other countries rather than other factors. Quite obviously, power will continue to play a central role in global politics, as it always does. But usually there is something else behind conflicts. In the 18th century in Europe, the issues to a large extent involved questions of monarchy versus the emerging republican movements, first in America and then in France. In the 19th century, it involved states identifying themselves through nationalism. In the 20th century, ideology came to the fore, largely, but not exclusively, as a result of the Russian Revolution. We had fascism, communism and liberal democracy competing with each other. Well, that’s pretty much over. Liberal democracy has come to be accepted, in theory at least, around the world, if not always in practice. So the question really is what will be the central focus of global politics in the coming decades? My argument remains that cultural identities, antagonisms and affiliations will not only play a role, but play a major role in relations between states. The full interview is here.

This is the 3rd

Every citizen in the City of Richardson will be able to access 756 Kbps of internet connectivity for free, from anywhere in the city. They will be able to access the internet from their homes, schools, restaurants and parks using standard wi-fi connections which are now installed on almost every notebook computer. That is almost as fast as many so-called high speed broadband connections that one pays dearly for today, and several times faster than the various hotspots at your local coffee shops. And I should note that the tax-payers of the City of Richardson are not paying one penny for this, and in fact are going to see additional revenues as a benefit. ... At the beginning of this letter, I suggested that this would be one of the fastest worldwide rollouts of a technology ever seen. It was just 20 years ago that the first cellular systems were being built. The rollout for mesh wireless systems is going to make that look slow. There are several reasons I make this assertion. But they all center on the facts that installing mesh systems will be cheaper and easier than any previous system and the economics in both the developed and especially the developing world will be so radically compelling. Throw in the fact the any astute politician will want to be at the front of this parade (They will all want to say, "I was the man who helped bring free internet to everyone!") and the groundwork is laid for rapid deployment. In Richardson and elsewhere, MeshLinx is offering the basic infrastructure for free. This avoids all the time consuming, political budget battles in the cities. When a service is offered for free, much of the mandated competitive process is eliminated. Next is the low cost of installation of the system. As noted above, Richardson is a city of roughly 100,000 people living in 27.4 square miles. It will "only" cost about $2,000,000 today to lay the wireless blanket I mentioned above. It will cost a great deal less in the future, as MeshLinx is building the pods at a pace of 100 a month today. The maximum output of the US pilot assembly line is 500 a month. When the demand exceeds this (and it will in a very short time) discussions have been held to move volume production to China. Of course, the world will need tens of millions of pods. The cost for a pod will be a fraction of today's cost, with that installation number for a city like Richardson soon being half (or less) the cost of today. What does that $1 or 2 million get you? The infrastructure to be an internet connection, telephone, security, entertainment provider and a whole lot more company. As noted, it will get cheaper as the number of pods being made each month rises, thus lowering their costs dramatically. This technology does have scale. The cost of physically putting up a pod is not a large part of the equation, as you simply need to run a power line, attach a few bolts to a mount on the side of a building or light pole and then off to the next point. Think about the 40,000 homes and businesses in Richardson. If and (hopefully) over time when 10% decide to pay $50 a month for 10-20 Mbps high speed internet access you could see a revenue of $2.5 million a year just from internet access. Now add in all the other income possibilities (phone, entertainment, security and don't forget advertising revenue on the free service!). Think about your town or country. What would service like this be worth? If you are a small city that does not have high speed connections available, how many businesses that could bring jobs do not come your way because they need reliable communications for their work and their employees? If you are in a developing country, where internet access is difficult and expensive, it will open whole new vistas. Couple that with the various programs which want to give cheap laptops to kids in poor countries, and you could see significant social progress in a generation. Here is the link.

Saturday, July 29, 2006

The genesis of the dam

I should not go away without telling you of the genesis of Tipaimukh dam as seen from Imphal.

It must be 7/8 years ago. There was a 2-day open discussion on Tipaimukh in Manipur University. To my mind, it was the first organized selling of Tipaimukh dam to the general public of Manipur. It was bankrolled by Brahmaputra Board. It was efficiently organized with all the paperworks, backgrounders and the actual technical feasibility reports etc duly made available to all the people who happened to come to attend the discussion. It was also a well attended discussion session.

Only during those two days I came to have an inkling of the structure of the Government of India for organizing electrical resources. At the top is CEC ie, Central Electricity Commission, a statutory entity created by an act of Parliament. For the North East there is this Brahmaputra Board, also an entity created by an act of parliament. The Board seems to be created for keeping a focus on the electrical resources for the NE and it reports to CEC.

A team of high level officials from the Brahmaputra Board was in attendance. They had seen with their own eyes how there was no taker for the proposed dam at Tipaimukh. The handful of attendees who had spoken in favor of the dam were the Kuki-chin-mizo people of around Tipaimukh, who were going so because they were going to get largesse from the Board as the compensation of lands likely to be acquired for the dam.

There were no takers for the dam.

We thought that the dam was as good as dead from the perspectives of the people of Manipur because there was such an overwhelming opposition to it.

It was only after several years down the line that reports on newspapers surfaced stating that NEEPCO was lobbying hard the MLAs and ministers for finalizing a MOU for the construction of the dam. There were protests against the proposed MOU. The government said that they were shelving the process that lead to the signing of the MOU.

NEEPCO is another of those entity created by an act of parliament but unlike the Brahmaputra Board, they are mandated to carry out the commercial facet for mobilizing electrical resources from the NE.

After some months they signed the MOU on the sly and came to the press saying they had done that for the future of the State!

There were only sporadic protests.

It was only some ago when those disparate protesting groups could coalesce into a State-wide apex body. The move was spearheaded by the people from Tamenglong district because they will be heaviest losers if the dam is constructed.

They are facing the prospect of losing all their heritage sites under the water of the dam. Inside Tamenglong district the water level of the
lake formed by the proposed dam would rise so high that a substantial portions of the present NH 53 would be inundated. NEEPCO proposed to lay brand new highway on the higher reaches of the Tamenglong hills!

Needless to say, the water from the proposed dam will inundate parts of Noney which is barely 45 kms from Imphal.

The proposed dam is a disaster not only for Tamenglong district but also of the whole of Manipur. A real DISASTER in the making.