My recent posts has a lot to do with history,particularly of Manipur's history.The surprising element is,of course,the Pongs.
This reminds me of another surprise.How do we figure out the 42 days long single object exhibition of Paubi Lai in New Delhi recently?Even if we don't try to answer this question,a simple reading together of the exhibition and the recent developments that prompt the focussing of our attention to the Pongs makes it quite clear that New Delhi is currently doing a lot of dissection of Manipuri society.I think that many scholars of Manipuri society are imvolved in the said dissection of the Manipuri society.
What attracted my attention at that time was the explanatory note accompanying the announcement of the exhibition.More precisely,the last part of the note,which says that the Paubi Lai was killed by none other than Kabui Salang Maiba,who,of course,belong to a small ethnic minority in the hills of Manipur.
The narrative--small ethnic minorities of the hills versus the major ethnic grouping in the valley.
That brings us to the pattern-smashing visit of special secretary(internal security),New Delhi to Churachandpur district in Manipur.The special secretary,like a seasoned politician, went straight to a meeting public.It was quite a spectacle seeing the senior beaurocrat from Nelhi addressing a public meeting in Churachandpur district of Manipur.
Of course,the special secretary made it a point visiting the place on the same day the Chinese president started his maidenn state to the US.During the address to the public meeting he emphasized that the Churachandpur turmoil is much more than an internal matter of the state of Manipur.The word 'internal' on the day of Chinese president's US visit,that too,from a person located firmly inside the power corridors of New Delhi attains a disproportionate singnificance.
But,is that the purpose of the special secretary's visit?
The short answer--NO.
The special secretary,which represents New Delhi,is aiming for a fundamental shift in how the Manipuri society finds its equilibrium.
Let's start out from the present mood of the Manipuri society.The overwhelming perception is that what is happening right now in the hills,particularly,in Churachandpur,is the direct results of the machinations of New Delhi.In such a scenario,New Delhi should hide the behind the screen and continues to pull strings from there.
But New Delhi suddenly jumps out from behind the screen and shows to all concerned that the show is actually run by it.
Why?
We are facing with a profound question.
To say that they are trying to provoke the valley community is too apparent.It also brings back the game to New Delhi vs Manipuri society scheme of things.New Delhi has been trying to avoid this scheme of thing,showing to all concerned the that the assent to the three is not forthcoming because the hills peoples are against the bills.This is the pattern which should be thrown up by this scheme of things.
What happens if we break the pattern?By being 'too apparent',are they trying to elicit a more sinister provocation from the valley society?
Let's go back to the Pong paradigm.Several centuries back,the Pongs might behave just like hillmen of today.It's because the Pongs appear to tbe the least assimilated of the numerous streams of people coming here in the cauldron called the Manipuri society.Let's call them the new Pong.As we are witnessing at the moment,the new Pongs have no qualm of publicly courting New Delhi for achieving its political goal.
But the older Pongs within the Manipuri society does not have this luxury.They might have courted New Delhi but they have this compulsion to do it covertly.Publicly,their posture should be anti-New Delhi and they are working for the indigenoous people of Manipuri.
At this point of time,New Delhi is in possesion of some data set which in a simulated scenario points to the increasing vulnerability of the older Pongs within the Manipuri society as New Delhi steps up its 'too apparent' postures.As New delhi continues stepping up this posture,the vulnerability of the older Pongs intensified until it reaches a breaking point.
It would be suicidal for the older Pongs if this breaking point ever comes about.In such a situation,the older Pongs have the lone option of attacking the New Pongs to prevent New Delhi from stepping up the 'too apparent' postures,as they have no the wherewithal to attack New Delhi.
This is the only scenario which I can think of why New Delhi suddenly jumps out from behind the screen.
Is it a plausible scenario?I wonder.
This reminds me of another surprise.How do we figure out the 42 days long single object exhibition of Paubi Lai in New Delhi recently?Even if we don't try to answer this question,a simple reading together of the exhibition and the recent developments that prompt the focussing of our attention to the Pongs makes it quite clear that New Delhi is currently doing a lot of dissection of Manipuri society.I think that many scholars of Manipuri society are imvolved in the said dissection of the Manipuri society.
What attracted my attention at that time was the explanatory note accompanying the announcement of the exhibition.More precisely,the last part of the note,which says that the Paubi Lai was killed by none other than Kabui Salang Maiba,who,of course,belong to a small ethnic minority in the hills of Manipur.
The narrative--small ethnic minorities of the hills versus the major ethnic grouping in the valley.
That brings us to the pattern-smashing visit of special secretary(internal security),New Delhi to Churachandpur district in Manipur.The special secretary,like a seasoned politician, went straight to a meeting public.It was quite a spectacle seeing the senior beaurocrat from Nelhi addressing a public meeting in Churachandpur district of Manipur.
Of course,the special secretary made it a point visiting the place on the same day the Chinese president started his maidenn state to the US.During the address to the public meeting he emphasized that the Churachandpur turmoil is much more than an internal matter of the state of Manipur.The word 'internal' on the day of Chinese president's US visit,that too,from a person located firmly inside the power corridors of New Delhi attains a disproportionate singnificance.
But,is that the purpose of the special secretary's visit?
The short answer--NO.
The special secretary,which represents New Delhi,is aiming for a fundamental shift in how the Manipuri society finds its equilibrium.
Let's start out from the present mood of the Manipuri society.The overwhelming perception is that what is happening right now in the hills,particularly,in Churachandpur,is the direct results of the machinations of New Delhi.In such a scenario,New Delhi should hide the behind the screen and continues to pull strings from there.
But New Delhi suddenly jumps out from behind the screen and shows to all concerned that the show is actually run by it.
Why?
We are facing with a profound question.
To say that they are trying to provoke the valley community is too apparent.It also brings back the game to New Delhi vs Manipuri society scheme of things.New Delhi has been trying to avoid this scheme of thing,showing to all concerned the that the assent to the three is not forthcoming because the hills peoples are against the bills.This is the pattern which should be thrown up by this scheme of things.
What happens if we break the pattern?By being 'too apparent',are they trying to elicit a more sinister provocation from the valley society?
Let's go back to the Pong paradigm.Several centuries back,the Pongs might behave just like hillmen of today.It's because the Pongs appear to tbe the least assimilated of the numerous streams of people coming here in the cauldron called the Manipuri society.Let's call them the new Pong.As we are witnessing at the moment,the new Pongs have no qualm of publicly courting New Delhi for achieving its political goal.
But the older Pongs within the Manipuri society does not have this luxury.They might have courted New Delhi but they have this compulsion to do it covertly.Publicly,their posture should be anti-New Delhi and they are working for the indigenoous people of Manipuri.
At this point of time,New Delhi is in possesion of some data set which in a simulated scenario points to the increasing vulnerability of the older Pongs within the Manipuri society as New Delhi steps up its 'too apparent' postures.As New delhi continues stepping up this posture,the vulnerability of the older Pongs intensified until it reaches a breaking point.
It would be suicidal for the older Pongs if this breaking point ever comes about.In such a situation,the older Pongs have the lone option of attacking the New Pongs to prevent New Delhi from stepping up the 'too apparent' postures,as they have no the wherewithal to attack New Delhi.
This is the only scenario which I can think of why New Delhi suddenly jumps out from behind the screen.
Is it a plausible scenario?I wonder.
No comments:
Post a Comment